Ten reasons why Romania’s proposed mass-kill of millions of stray dogs won’t work and two reasons why it might

An English version of a comment piece published here in Romania’s top news and opinion website, Hotnews: http://www.contributors.ro/editorial/zece-motive-pentru-care-propunerea-romaniei-de-a-ucide-in-masa-milioane-de-caini-nu-va-functiona-si-doua-motive-pentru-care-s-ar-putea-sa-functioneze/

No one wants dogs on the streets in Romania. In a country with up to two million loose canines, no one is standing on a pedestal in the centre of Bucharest shouting We Want More Dogs! We want a Dog for every school! In every office, a mandatory dog at every desk! Two dogs for every church!
For four years I have been writing about and filming stray dogs in Romania, including a film, ‘Man’s Best Friend’, released on Vimeo this week: https://vimeo.com/74578670
During this time, mayors, residents and dog lovers alike all agreed – no more dogs on the streets.
However when the council of a town in east Romania, Botosani, killed 200 dogs in 2011, there was a rumour that a local animal activist group was planning a ‘Dog Bomb’.
A ‘Dog Bomb’ is where pet-loving extremists orchestrate fertile dogs to breed over a six-week period and, once they have hundreds of puppies, they set the animals loose in the city. Dog anarchy follows. But it was only a rumour. No one – not even the Dog Bombers of Botosani – wants dogs on the streets.
So if everyone has the same end in mind, why can’t they agree on the means?
Following the horrific canine attack on a four year-old boy in Bucharest earlier this month, Mayor of Bucharest Sorin Oprescu pushed through a new law allowing councils to kill strays after 14 days in captivity – in a move fiercely contested by animal rights activists and now under dispute in Romania’s Constitutional Court.
Here are ten reasons why this new law may not solve the problem of dogs on the streets – and two reasons why it might.

1. In a massive city, with a mass of dogs, mass-killing is rarely effective. The more dogs you kill, the more space and food there is for new dogs. The World Health Organisation backs this up. As long as people dump dogs on the street and let dogs loose on the street to breed, there will be more dogs. When dogs disappear, other dogs appear.
2. To kill the animals, cities need vets. Vets must want to kill the animals. But many vets don’t want to murder. People did not study for six years to swap the surgery for the slaughterhouse. Last month in southwest city of Timisoara the vets voted not to collaborate with City Hall to kill the dogs. More could follow.
3. All dogs must die – except mine. When Romanians are surveyed, they say they want to kill strays. But if you ask the same Romanians, if they want to see the charming,  big brown-eyed mutt which greets them every day with a cocked head and a wagging tail, killed by lethal injection, they will refuse. Because this dog is kind to children, friendly to strangers and he never bites – and, when he does bite, it’s because he’s scared. It is always other people’s dogs who are dangerous. The dogs in the other block. In the other yard. In the other city.
4. Bucharest tried mass-murder. As Mayor of Bucharest, Traian Basescu ordered the killing of around 100,000 dogs between 2001 and 2003. It failed.
5. The wrong dogs will die. The dog catchers will pick up the quiet, old, sad and castrated dogs – the ones that can’t breed. The problem is not just stray dogs. The problem is loose dogs. I’ve followed dog catching around the housing areas of the Bucharest suburbs. When the residents leave for work in the morning, they let their dogs out on the street. If they are caught by dog catchers, the owners pick them up from the shelter and pay a fine. These are virile dogs. They breed with strays. They create new puppies. The problem persists.
6. People will hide the dogs. There are a lot of old, single and idle people in Bucharest. Often they love dogs. They will be watching for the dog catchers and, if they come for their strays, they will conceal them in their flat, basement, garage or yard.
7. No-kill could become a black market. In the past, dog catchers in Bucharest took money from residents in blocks to leave their stray dogs alone. This could happen again.
8. It is hard to catch a dog. There are around 15 trained dog catchers for three million people of Bucharest and its suburbs. They catch dogs by shooting them with a tranquilizer gun loaded with sedatives such as ketamine. The city will need a batallion of trained marskmen who can be trusted with a gun and a litre of a party drug with a high street value.
9. Bucharest is a metropolis run by a village council. It can’t cope with grand projects and grand challenges. Or even small ones. I live on Piata Unirii – a square at the centre of the city. An international showpiece. In one year, they have not finished re-surfacing the pavement. It is a building site of dust, mud, rocks and holes. If Bucharest cannot lay a few paving stones in its city centre, it cannot manage the mass-murder of over 50,000 lives.
10. The capital never gave other solutions a chance. Councillors will argue back that the NGOs’ favoured idea of the sterilisation and the return of dogs to the streets does not work, because stray dog attacks on people keep rising. But the City never tried a mass-scale programme to see whether the dog numbers would fall. If, over a five year period, many NGOs could co-ordinate professional sterilisation in conjunction with all seven City Halls of Bucharest and the surrounding county of Ilfov, alongside comprehensive adoption and education about responsible ownership, while giving the authorities the right to euthanize sick, old and aggressive dogs, the problem could stop.

And two reasons why it might work…

1. Under the new law, in a small city in Romania, it will probably be possible to round and kill up to 1,000 stray dogs. But in Bucharest, this needs an unprecedented effort. The city needs to declare war on dogs. It needs a militia to go block by block, possibly forcing residents to leave their homes, while police carry out searches, removing every dog they suspect of being a stray. There must be no exceptions. They must enforce the 14-day rule before murdering the dogs. Killing 60,000 dogs means a massacre – and a massacre can only be effective if is ruthless and mechanical.
2. Politicians enlist citizens to be vigilantes. Using the media, politicians demonize all dogs as violent. The Government passes a new law allowing dogs to be killed. This sends a signal to citizens that they have the liberty to beat, poison, run over or lynch any loose dog. Anecdotally, friends are telling me of how bodies of dogs are appearing more often on the outskirts of Bucharest. If the nation’s leaders keep up the rhetoric, this may continue. The streets will be running with blood and poison and the blocks will be echoing with the sound of bats against brains until the last stray in Bucharest is dead – while the authorities bear no responsibility.

Advertisements

22 thoughts on “Ten reasons why Romania’s proposed mass-kill of millions of stray dogs won’t work and two reasons why it might

  1. Damn you Romania with your stupid leaders, I am sorry for being romanian! Someone stop this idiotic people, I don’t care how… PLEASE!!! I can’t belive we are capable of doing such thing… I’ve seen pictures of killed dogs and was disturbing, i hope i won’t lose my mind and do something stupid too… One more thing, they are not “killed by lethal injection”, investigate the case and you will be stunned. God please give more neurons to some humans!
    Check this facebook account and see for yourself: https://www.facebook.com/claudia.erdmann.142

    • Please dont do anything crazy – solutions need to be met through the people, vets and whole villages (towns) supporting the management of the problem, instead of people wanting to catch and kill, why not report and fine those caught not caring, or dumping puppies

  2. Pingback: Musta päivä Romaniassa. Vihaa, pelkoa, tuskaa. | Fifirock - Home of Happy Dogs

  3. Pingback: nobody´s dogs = nobody´s care? | My Blog Straydogsworldwide

  4. All those dogs deserve nothing but love and security. Here is a video tribute to stray dogs all over the world including Romania. This problem sickens my heart continually and has for a long time. We really have to stop the breeding, get at the root, stop the insanity, it is too horrible for words:

  5. I am currently sponsoring 3 dogs in Romanian shelters because I have only cats at home and I urge all people who have to financial means and the needed compassionate soul to ADOPT from our country. It is the only way, our authorities are intent on committing horrendous murders against the dogs. Save them by adopting!

    • the biggest scandal of what is happening to the dogs is that it is peoples own fault that there are so many on the streets, people themselves put them there and now these dogs have to pay for it with there lives, and it is still not proven that the child was killed by dogs, no one has been seen a photo of a dead child, its the boys parents that want these murders!!shame on them and its all about money!

  6. dogs will be So just wonderful we appreciate dogs And far.
    Dogs be Everyone laugh I really would like on acknowledge
    care Of most additional dogs. Thank on you dogs. DOGS work as great!

  7. Have you ever considered creating an e-book or guest authoring on other sites?
    I have a blog based on the same topics you discuss and would love
    to have you share some stories/information. I
    know my subscribers would appreciate your work. If you’re even remotely interested, feel free to send me an e mail.

  8. Although the Court has declared the current legislation out of force so that currently there is no legal frame for the campaign to collect and kill stray dogs, the campaign is currently under way with the consent of the local authorities of Bucharest city and surrounding localities.
    Now they come at midnight accompanied by masked police officers, outside the limits of Bucharest city limits, enter private properties and take dogs out of their kennels and one has to face the masked if trying to recover the dogs.
    In addition, the entity in charge of this campaign states that it does not operate outside the limits of Bucharest; however, they recommend to identify the dog at one of their shelters. No one answers the phone at these shelters and it becomes simply a nightmare the search for one’s dog which has to be carried out rather quickly in a matter of a day or two, otherwise the dogs are killed.
    No one listens to you, although they are paid from public money.
    All this is a result of the lack of measures which could have been applied over the last years and which would have resulted in the decrease of stray dogs. Not to forget the fact that they are paid around 440 euro per stray dog collected!
    Please help in any way that you can before it turns into an even greater nightmare.
    Georgiana

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s